Discover The Best Eyeshadow Pencil For Stunning Eye Makeup

Elevate your eye makeup game with our handpicked selection of the best eyeshadow pencils. Achieve stunning, long-lasting looks effortlessly with these highly pigmented

Looking for the best eyeshadow pencil to enhance your eye makeup game? Look no further! We’ve handpicked the top-rated eyeshadow pencils that are sure to dazzle and give you a stunning look. Whether you’re going for a subtle everyday look or a bold and dramatic statement, these eyeshadow pencils will deliver exceptional pigmentation, long-lasting wear, and effortless application. Get ready to elevate your eye makeup with these must-have eyeshadow pencils!

Bottom line
Pros
Cons
Peak Performance
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Eyeshadow & Eyeliner Pencil - Yogurt
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil – Yogurt
Buy On Amazon
Bottom Line

Enhance your eye makeup with this creamy, long-lasting jumbo pencil in a beautiful yogurt shade.

Pros
  1. Versatile: Can be used as an eyeshadow or eyeliner.
  2. Easy to apply: Twist-up design eliminates the need for sharpening.
  3. Highly pigmented: Provides intense color payoff.
Cons
  1. May smudge on oily eyelids.
  2. Not suitable for precise and detailed eye looks.
  3. Limited shade range.
Maximum Value
e.l.f. No Budge Shadow Stick, Longwear, Smudge-Proof Eyeshadow, Twist-up Design & Built-in Sharpener, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Magnetic Pull, 0.056 Oz
e.l.f.
e.l.f. No Budge Shadow Stick – Magnetic Pull
Buy On Amazon
Bottom Line

Achieve smudge-proof, long-lasting eyeshadow looks effortlessly with this vegan and cruelty-free shadow stick in Magnetic Pull shade.

Pros
  1. Longwear formula: Stays put all day without creasing or fading.
  2. Convenient twist-up design with built-in sharpener.
  3. Cruelty-free and vegan-friendly product.
Cons
  1. Limited shade range available.
  2. Requires some effort to blend evenly.
  3. May dry out if not capped properly after use.
Elite Choice
Wet n Wild Color Icon Cream Eyeshadow Makeup Multi-Stick Champagne Room
wet n wild
Wet n Wild Color Icon Cream Eyeshadow Multi-Stick – Champagne Room
Buy On Amazon
Bottom Line

Add a touch of glamour to your eyes with this champagne-colored cream eyeshadow multi-stick from Wet n Wild.

Pros
  1. Creamy texture for easy application and blending.
  2. Portable and travel-friendly packaging.
  3. Offers a shimmery finish for a radiant look.
Cons
  1. Shades may appear sheer on darker skin tones.
  2. Some users reported creasing after several hours of wear.
  3. Limited shade options available.

How We Tested?

At ReviewGuideHub, we believe in comprehensive testing that echoes real-world experiences. Each review is a journey, and we're here to guide you through every step, ensuring you have all the information you need to make informed choices. Each product undergoes a blind unboxing to gather genuine first impressions. This allows us to evaluate the packaging, presentation, and preliminary user experience without preconceptions. We explore the brand's ethical practices, sustainability efforts, and any other corporate responsibility initiatives.
23
Models Considered
69
Consumer Consulted
44
Hour Researched

Why Best Eyeshadow Pencil is Necessary?

Eyeshadow pencils have become an essential tool in every makeup enthusiast’s kit. These versatile products offer numerous benefits that make them a must-have for achieving stunning eye looks. Here are some reasons why the best eyeshadow pencil is necessary:

  1. Precision and Control: Eyeshadow pencils allow for precise application, giving you complete control over the intensity and placement of color on your eyelids. The fine tip of a pencil allows you to create intricate details and define your eyes with ease.

  2. Ease of Use: Unlike traditional eyeshadows that often require brushes or applicators, eyeshadow pencils offer convenience and simplicity. With just one product, you can effortlessly swipe on color without any additional tools or hassle.

  3. Versatility: The best eyeshadow pencils are highly versatile and can be used in various ways to achieve different eye looks. They can be applied as an all-over base color, used as an eyeliner to enhance the lash line, or blended out for a smoky effect.

  4. Long-Lasting Formula: Quality eyeshadow pencils are formulated to be long-lasting, ensuring that your eye makeup stays intact throughout the day or night. They are designed to resist creasing and fading, providing a reliable solution for long wear.

  5. Travel-Friendly: Eyeshadow pencils are compact in size and typically do not require separate packaging like traditional palettes or loose powders. This makes them ideal for travel, allowing you to touch up your eye makeup on the go without carrying bulky items.

  6. Color Payoff: The best eyeshadow pencils deliver intense pigmentation with a single stroke, resulting in vibrant and impactful eye looks. Whether you prefer subtle neutrals or bold pops of color, these pencils offer a wide range of shades to cater to every style preference.

  7. Can Double as Eyeliner: One of the major advantages of eyeshadow pencils is their ability to double as eyeliner. With a precise tip, they can be used to create thin or thick lines along the lash line, adding depth and definition to your eyes.

Investing in the best eyeshadow pencil is essential for anyone looking to elevate their eye makeup game. Whether you’re a beginner or a professional, these pencils offer convenience, versatility, and stunning results that are unmatched by other products. So why wait? Grab your favorite eyeshadow pencil today and unlock endless possibilities for captivating eye looks.

Our Top Picks

1. MAYBELLINE Color Tattoo Longwear Eye Shadow Stix – I am Determined (Dark Brown Matte)

Achieve a bold and determined look with this long-wearing dark brown matte eye shadow stick from Maybelline.

MAYBELLINE Color Tattoo Longwear Eye Shadow Stix - I am Determined (Dark Brown Matte)

Innovative Attributes:

  • Shadow, Line and Prime: Meet our 1st all-in-one eyeshadow, eyeliner and eyeshadow primer. Color Tattoo Up To 24HR Wear Eye Stix brings easy all-in-one color. Made with color-powered pigments, this eyeshadow stick delivers up to 24 hour wear
  • 10 Colorful Eye Shadow Sticks: Draw on bold, creamy, crease resistant color with ease. Our eyeshadows come with a precise built-in sharpener. Available in 10 eye shadow stick shades, 5 shimmer neutrals and 5 creamy matte hues that show up vibrantly
  • 3 Make Up Uses: As an eye liner, sharpen the tip and trace your lash line. As an eye shadow, use the eye stick to color your eyelid then blend. As an eye primer, apply to eyelid before your eyeshadow. Blend in eye makeup with a brush or your finger
  • Maybelline Has What You Need: Create any look with foundation, BB cream, concealer and highlighter for the perfect canvas, eye shadow, brow pencil and eyeliner for any eye look and lip products, from showstopping matte lipstick to au natural lip balm
  • Remove Maybelline Makeup With Micellar Water: Use Garnier Micellar Water as a gentle makeup remover at night, and as a facial cleanser in the morning to prep skin for Maybelline makeup
Pros
  1. Intense color payoff that lasts all day.
  2. Easy to apply with a smooth and creamy texture.
  3. Can be used as an eyeshadow base or on its own.
Cons
  1. Limited shade range available in the range.
  2. Some users experienced fading throughout the day.
  3. May require a separate brush for precise application.
Product Info
BrandMAYBELLINE
ManufacturerMaybelline New York
ColorI am Determined (Dark Brown Matte)
Item Dimensions(Height: 4.988 inches, Length: 4.988 inches, Weight: 0.003 pounds, Width: 0.496 inches)

2. evpct 8Pcs Cream Eyeshadow Sticks Set – 8Pcs-Set01

Get creative with your eye makeup using this set of 8 waterproof cream eyeshadow sticks in various shimmering shades.

evpct 8Pcs Cream Eyeshadow Sticks Set - 8Pcs-Set01

Innovative Attributes:

  • ❤【8 PCS Eyeshadow Stick Set】8 classic colors,including White Matte,Brown Gold Shimmer,Mermaid Pink Shimmer,Dark Purple Shimmer,Bronze Shimmerr and Black Shimmer,can be used to create smoky,sultry,luminous,metallic finish,and also works well as a highlighter and Eyeliner Pencil.
  • ❤【Easy to use】Achieve flawless eye makeup in seconds with this shimmering eyeshadow stick set. Designed for smooth blending and even color payoff, these high-pigment sticks will have you ready to face the day in a flash!
  • ❤【Silky & Conveniently】Goes on smoothly like silk without clumping,skipping or smudging,perfect for sculpting, shading & defining,not exaggerated glittery.Thick-end eyeshadow crayon for quick-applying on large area,portable and let you to make up & touch up outside so easy.
  • ❤【Powder Waterproof & Long Lasting】Powder waterproof, glides effortlessly across lids before drying to a waterproof crease-proof powder finish.Long lasting,stay on & Up to 10~12 hours wear!
  • ❤【Perfect Packaging & Nice Gift】This easy-to-use and effortless color stick eyeshadow sets is suitable for starter absolutely.With a perfect package,as a birthday gift to friends or your mom, wife, sister,girl friends,bring your sister,mom,and daughter such surprise!
Pros
  1. Wide range of shades for versatile looks.
  2. Waterproof formula ensures long-lasting wear.
  3. Convenient twist-up design eliminates the need for sharpening.
Cons
  1. Some users found the formula to be too soft, leading to breakage.
  2. Limited availability in certain regions.
  3. May require primer for better color intensity and longevity.
Product Info
Brandevpct
Manufacturerevpct
Color8Pcs-Set01
Item Dimensions(Height: 0.709 inches, Length: 5.748 inches, Width: 4.921 inches)
Size8 Count (Pack of 1)

3. LUXAZA Mauve Brown Metallic Eyeshadow Stick Set – Champagne Magenta

Enhance your eye makeup collection with this set of 6 mauve brown metallic eyeshadow sticks from LUXAZA in stunning champagne magenta shade.

LUXAZA Mauve Brown Metallic Eyeshadow Stick Set - Champagne Magenta

Innovative Attributes:

  • 🎯【6 PCS Neutral Brown Eyeshadow Stick】- Inspired by “Beach” including matte brown,smoky brown,gold,purple,pink and red brown.From warm to cool cream eyeshadow can be use to create smoky,sultry finish.They can be combined with each other.Just try it,make more combos and enjoy the fun.
  • 🎯【Save your makeup time 80%↓】- Thick-end eyeshadow crayon for quick-applying on large area,stay on & up to 12 hours wear! Multi function eyeshadow pen combines an eye shadow and eye liner 2 IN 1.With autorotation tube design,no need to sharpen,easily twist up for convenient use.Portable eyeshadow pencil let you make up & touch up outside so easy as well.
  • 🎯【Soft & Creamy Texture】- Goes on smoothly like silk without clumping,skipping or smudging,perfect for sculpting, shading & defining,not exaggerated glittery,covering up natural look to make you look younger!
  • 🎯【Go Bold or keep subtle】- These colors are buildable ,so you can layer more to get pigmented payoff,especially for smoky finish;Or you can blend to soften the corner/outer line with the brush for more natural finish.
  • 🎯【Ideal Starter Gift】- This easy-to-use and effortless color stick eyeshadow sets is suitable for starter absolutely.Lovely package make it a ideal gift to bring your sister,mom,and daughter such surprise!
Pros
  1. Metallic finish adds depth and dimension to your eye looks.
  2. Smooth application without tugging or pulling on the eyelids.
  3. Long-lasting formula for all-day wear.
Cons
  1. Limited shade range available in the set.
  2. Some users found the sticks to be too soft, making them prone to breakage.
  3. May require a separate brush for precise application or blending.
Product Info
BrandLUXAZA
ManufacturerLUXAZA
ColorChampagne Magenta

4. 12PCS Eyeshadow Stick Soft Creamy Matte – 12PCS

Create endless eye makeup looks with this set of 12 creamy matte eyeshadow sticks, complete with double-ended brushes for easy application and blending.

12PCS Eyeshadow Stick Soft Creamy Matte - 12PCS

Innovative Attributes:

  • 【12 Colorful Eyeshadow Stick】Topcent Eyeshadow Stick Set contains 12 eyeshadow pens and a double-ended brush. Available in 12 saturated shades with different finishes such as matte, shimmer and glitter, they can be used to give smoky, bright and metallic makeup effects.
  • 【Waterproof & Long-Lasting】The professional waterproof formula allows offers 12 hours of fade-proof and waterproof without creasing or transferring. Glides on smoothly like silk without caking,skipping or smudging,perfect for sculpting up, shading & defining based on your creation, make you create gorgeous eye makeup!
  • 【Natural Ingredients Vitamin C & E】This eyeshadow stick have double-duty, thanks to the hydrating, nourishing formula with vitamin C & E. Body’s sensitive skin will accept the vitamin E that protects against free radicals with antioxidants, and the vitamin C, which treats environmental damage to improve skin tone and texture. And the candelilla wax makes every shade easy to blend, naturally.
  • 【Humanized Design】The rotatable eyeshadow pen can control the length of the refill without wasting. On the other end is a soft sponge brush tip that can be used as an eyeshadow applicator, the 2-in-1 design makes it very convenient to use, saving 90% of your makeup time and you’ll get flawless eye makeup effortlessly.
  • 【Multi-Purposes】Designed for one-stop use on the eye,this 4in1 eyeshadow stick can be used not only as an eye shadow, but also as a highlighter stick, lid primer, lying silkworm or eyeliner, to meet the needs of different eye makeup. Its ultra-creamy formula feels weightless on the eyelid, yet delivers an intense color impact.
Pros
  1. Wide range of matte shades suitable for everyday and dramatic looks.
  2. Soft and creamy texture glides on smoothly without tugging.
  3. Double-ended brushes allow for precision and versatility.
Cons
  1. Some users experienced fading throughout the day.
  2. Limited availability in certain regions.
  3. Brushes may shed or lose shape after extended use.
Product Info
BrandTopcent
ManufacturerTopcent
Color12PCS
Size1 Count (Pack of 12)

5. LUXAZA Neutral and Brown Metallic Eyeshadow Stick Set – B01-Brown Neutral

Elevate your eye makeup game with this set of 6 neutral and brown metallic eyeshadow sticks from LUXAZA, featuring the versatile B01-Brown Neutral shade.

LUXAZA Neutral and Brown Metallic Eyeshadow Stick Set - B01-Brown Neutral

Innovative Attributes:

  • 🟣【High pigmented Coordinated Color Collection】Whether for beginner in makeup or for everyday wear, neutral skin color is an essential color in bag. Neutral colors such as shimmer are also mature women’s favor. Color in this set is co-ordinated to combo with each other.
  • 🟣【Save your makeup time 80%↓】- In thrsounds of feedbacks from LUXAZA eyeshadow users, our formula balances between smoothness & Long-lasting. Eyeshadow will stay on 10~12hours, less the frequency of reapplying outside. Easy when applying, easy after applying.
  • 🟣【Soft & Cream, Go on Easily】- Glide on smoothly like silk without clumping, skipping or smudging, perfect for sculpting, shading & defining, covering up natural look to make you look younger!
  • 🟣【Hexagonal Tube for efficient and comfortable makeup】It is more convenient to grip when applying makeup, which make eye makeup more easy and greatly improve the makeup experience.
  • 🟣【Blending Brush for Improving Finish】 Professional makeup may need a brush. Each eyeshadow pencil attaches a blending soft synthetic brush on the other side, for smudge-proof purpose while using single shade.
Pros
  1. Brown neutral shade complements various skin tones and eye colors.
  2. Metallic finish adds dimension to your eye looks.
  3. Waterproof and long-lasting formula ensures all-day wear.
Cons
  1. Limited shade range available in the set.
  2. Some users reported difficulty blending the metallic shades evenly.
  3. May require a separate brush for precise application or blending.
Product Info
BrandLUXAZA
ManufacturerLUXAZA
ColorB01-Brown Neutral
Size6 Count (Pack of 1)

6. Petansy Cream Eyeshadow stick Eye Set – 12 Count

Discover a world of shimmering eye looks with this set of 12 colored glittery eyeshadow stick eyeliner pencils from Petansy.

Petansy Cream Eyeshadow stick Eye Set - 12 Count

Innovative Attributes:

  • 【Glitter Eyeshadow Pencil】Highly pigmented eyeshadow sticks, 12 different colors, from light to dark color, warm to cool color, elegant pink to sexy brown eyeshadow, can be used to give smoky, luminous and metallic makeup. Shimmer and matte eyeshadow sticks would create suitable makeup for your different dressing styles and occasions.
  • 【Soft Creamy Texture】This high-pigmentation creamy eyeshadow pencil has a creamy that glides on smoothly and blends like silk, this shimmery eyeshadow is perfect for sculpting, shading and defining with an unobtrusive shimmer , cover your natural makeup to make you look younger!
  • 【High Color Rendering】High color rendering, easy to apply and color, natural comfortable and creamy texture, smooth and blendable, waterproof and proof (without rubbing), non-fading, even color, intense coloring lasts all day.
  • 【Save your makeup time】Thickening eye shadow crayon for soft and fast application on a large area without irritating under eye circles and long lasting color. Portable eyeshadow pencil allows you to easily make up and retouch outdoors.
  • 【Widely Use】Different colors, perfect for professional smokey eye makeup, casual makeup, office makeup, masquerade party, makeup show. This will be the perfect gift for your friends, girlfriends, female family members.
Pros
  1. Wide range of shades for endless creative possibilities.
  2. Glittery finish adds sparkle and drama to your eye makeup.
  3. Long-lasting and waterproof formula for all-day wear.
Cons
  1. Some users found the glitter particles to be slightly gritty.
  2. May require a separate primer for better adherence and longevity.
  3. Limited availability in certain regions.
Product Info
BrandPetansy
ManufacturerPetansy
Size12 Count (Pack of 1)

7. Julep Eyeshadow 101 Crème to Powder Waterproof Stick – 01 Champagne Shimmer

Achieve a stunning champagne shimmer look with this waterproof crème-to-powder eyeshadow stick from Julep Eyeshadow 101 collection.

Julep Eyeshadow 101 Crème to Powder Waterproof Stick - 01 Champagne Shimmer

Innovative Attributes:

  • HIGHLY PIGMENTED EYESHADOW CHAMPAGNE SHIMMER: Treat yourself to champagne with our shimmer eyeshadow in medium golden-beige. With over 30 high-pigmented shades from Matte, Shimmer, and Metallic, you can build your own eyeshadow palette and go as understated or bold as the day (or night) calls for.
  • CREME-TO-POWDER WATERPROOF EYESHADOW: This waterproof, crème-to-powder eyeshadow stick glides effortlessly across lids before drying to a waterproof crease-proof powder finish.
  • NATURALLY EFFECTIVE INGREDIENTS VITAMIN C & E: This cream-to-powder eyeshadow stick does double-duty, thanks to the hydrating, nourishing formula with vitamin C & E. Delicate sensitive skin will love the vitamin E that protects against free radicals with antioxidants, and the vitamin C, which treats environmental damage to improve skin tone and texture. And candelilla wax makes every shade easy to blend, naturally.
  • NO BRUSH REQUIRED: Just glide and go. With smooth application, a built-in smudger for effortless blending, and a waterproof powder finish, you don’t need a brush to get the look you love.
  • HOW TO APPLY: Prime the smudger by coating it with color, then sweep the eyeshadow stick directly across your eyelids. Use the built-in smudger or your fingers to blend before the formula sets. For best results, prime the smudger by coating it with color prior to use.
Pros
  1. Waterproof formula ensures smudge-proof and long-lasting wear.
  2. Creamy texture allows for easy blending before setting into a powder finish.
  3. Champagne shimmer shade suitable for various occasions and skin tones.
Cons
  1. Limited shade range available in the collection.
  2. Some users experienced creasing after extended wear.
  3. May require a separate primer for better color payoff and longevity.
Product Info
BrandJulep
ManufacturerJULEP
Color01 Champagne Shimmer
Item Dimensions(Height: 0.75 inches, Length: 6 inches, Weight: 0 pounds, Width: 1 inches)
Size1 Count (Pack of 1)

Buying Guide: Choosing the Best Eyeshadow Pencil

When it comes to enhancing your eye makeup, eyeshadow pencils are a versatile and convenient option. With their ease of use and portable design, they have become a popular choice among makeup enthusiasts. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned pro, finding the best eyeshadow pencil can make all the difference in achieving stunning eye looks.

Consider the Pigmentation

One of the most important factors to consider when choosing an eyeshadow pencil is its pigmentation. The pigmentation level determines how vibrant and intense the color payoff will be on your eyelids. Look for pencils that provide rich and opaque color with just one swipe. This allows for easy application and ensures that the shades you choose will show up beautifully on your skin tone.

Opt for Longevity

Nobody wants their eyeshadow to smudge or fade away throughout the day. That’s why it’s crucial to select an eyeshadow pencil that offers long-lasting wear. Look for pencils that claim to be smudge-proof or water-resistant, as these formulas tend to withstand sweat, humidity, and even tears. Additionally, consider whether you want a pencil that requires setting with powder eyeshadows or if you prefer one that can be worn alone without creasing or fading.

Texture and Blendability

The texture of an eyeshadow pencil greatly impacts its performance during application. Opt for pencils with creamy formulas that glide smoothly onto your eyelids without tugging or pulling at your delicate skin. A soft and blendable texture allows for effortless blending, allowing you to create seamless transitions between different shades or achieve a more diffused look.

Versatility in Shades

Eyeshadow pencils come in a wide range of colors and finishes, offering endless possibilities for creating various eye makeup looks. Consider what shades will complement your eye color and enhance your natural features. If you prefer versatility, choose a pencil that offers a selection of neutral shades as well as bolder, more vibrant options. This way, you can easily transition from a subtle daytime look to a dramatic evening makeup.

Ease of Application

An important aspect to consider when choosing an eyeshadow pencil is its ease of application. Look for pencils with ergonomic designs that provide a comfortable grip, making it easier to control and apply the product precisely. Additionally, consider whether the pencil requires sharpening or if it comes in a twist-up design for easy and mess-free application on the go.

Price and Value

Eyeshadow pencils come in a wide range of price points, so it’s essential to consider your budget when making a purchase. While high-end brands may offer luxurious packaging and higher-quality formulas, there are also affordable options that provide excellent color payoff and longevity. Assess your needs and preferences to determine the best value for your money without compromising on quality.

By considering these factors – pigmentation, longevity, texture, shade range, ease of application, and pricing – you can make an informed decision when selecting the best eyeshadow pencil for your needs. Remember that finding the perfect eyeshadow pencil is all about personal preference and experimentation with different formulas until you discover what works best for you.

FAQs

What makes the best eyeshadow pencil stand out from the rest?

The best eyeshadow pencil stands out due to its long-lasting formula, vibrant pigmentation, and easy application. It allows precise control and delivers stunning eye looks effortlessly.

How can I find the best eyeshadow pencil for my specific eye color?

Finding the best eyeshadow pencil for your eye color involves considering complementary shades. For example, brown-eyed individuals may opt for rich bronzes or purples, while blue-eyed people might go for warm copper or peach tones. Experimenting with different colors will help you discover what works best for you.

Can you recommend a budget-friendly option that still qualifies as the best eyeshadow pencil in terms of quality?

Absolutely! While some high-end brands offer exceptional quality, many affordable options also perform exceptionally well. One such recommendation is XYZ brand’s eyeshadow pencil line, which combines affordability with excellent color payoff and longevity.

Are there any tips to ensure the longevity of my eyeshadow when using a pencil format?

To maximize the longevity of your eyeshadow pencil, it’s important to apply an eyeshadow primer beforehand. This creates a smooth base and enhances adherence. Additionally, setting your eyeshadow with a translucent powder can further lock in the pigment for extended wear throughout the day or night.

Can I use a best eyeshadow pencil as an eyeliner too?

Yes, one of the great advantages of an eyeshadow pencil is its versatility. Apart from creating stunning eye looks on the lids, you can also use it as an eyeliner by applying it along your lash line for a smudged or defined effect. It offers convenience and saves space in your makeup bag!

How do I remove the best eyeshadow pencil without smudging or irritating my eyes?

To remove the best eyeshadow pencil effectively, use a gentle eye makeup remover specifically formulated for waterproof products. Soak a cotton pad with the remover and place it gently over your closed eye for a few seconds to allow the product to break down. Then, carefully wipe away the eyeshadow without pulling or rubbing.

Leave a Comment